Zinus vs. Tuft and Needle vs. Signature Sleep Mattress Comparison

This article compares Zinus, Tuft & Needle, and Signature Sleep.

All these brands are very popular when it comes to manufacturing reliable and comfortable mattresses for quality sleep.

The existence of these mattress brands in the market can make your decision quite challenging when it comes to buying a mattress that best suits your needs and preferences.

We will help you make an educated decision with our in-depth Zinus vs. Tuft and Needle vs. Signature Sleep mattress review comparison.

Zinus vs. Tuft and Needle vs. Signature Sleep Compared Side by Side


ZinusTuft and NeedleSignature Sleep
The cover of Zinus mattress is made of stretchy jacquard fabric. Their memory foam models feature covers that are soft and have snow-white color. All sides of the cover contain tiny holes that allow for free airflow, which helps with freshness and heat retention.The cover of Tuft & Needle mattress is quite basic and simple. It has a white tone and it is made of durable polyester Tactel and rayon fabric. The fabric is very thin and makes the mattress breathable and cool, giving you comfortable and cozier experience. It also has a zipper so you can easily remove it and wash the cover.Most of the Signature Sleep mattresses feature a cover that is made of bamboo or breathable knit fabric. The cover is soft, durable, and absorbs moisture well, hence creating a dry sleep surface. It is also very easy to clean.

The overall surface of the cover is smooth and offers breathability, which means you will sleep throughout the night without getting sweaty and uncomfortable due to heat buildup.

Construction (Materials & Quality)

ZinusTuft and NeedleSignature Sleep
Most of the Zinus mattress models contain four distinctive layers.

  • The first layer is 3-inches thick and offers support as well as has certain properties that minimize motion transfer.
  • The second layer is 2-inches thick and is made of comfort foam. It also provides support.
  • The third layer is 3.5-inches thick and is made of the material that is very dense. The purpose of this layer is to regulate heat retention.
  • The fourth layer serves as the base support and is 3.5-inches thick. It also helps regulate temperature.

All these layers work together to create a soothing and soft feel with a strong support element.

There are two layers.

  • The top layer is 3-inches thick and it is made of polyurethane foam. This layer has been designed to provide cooling and comfort.
  • The bottom or base layer is 7-inches thick and is also made of polyurethane foam. The main purpose of this layer is to provide support, but it also has cooling properties.
There are two layers of Signature Sleep 12-inch thick mattresses.

  • The top layer is 4-inches thick and is made of high-quality memory foam. The main purpose of this layer is to offer comfortable, body-contouring benefits to sleepers.
  • The bottom layer is 8-inches thick and is made of high-density base foam. This layer has been designed to offer core support to the mattresses and maintain its structural integrity over a long period of time. It offers good support to sleeper’s body as well.


Zinus vs Tuft and Needle vs Signature Sleep - Construction


Firmness (Support & Comfort)

ZinusTuft and NeedleSignature Sleep
From the firmness scale of 1-10, Zinus mattress has a rating of 5. It is neither too soft not too hard.

The mattress conforms well to sleeper’s body. It is also quite responsive, supportive, and bouncy at the same time. So even if you are a side sleeper, Zinus mattress will not hurt your pressure points.

As far as the edge support is concerned, Zinus mattress has very bouncy edges that don’t sag too much under the sleeper’s weight.

On a firmness scale of 1-10, Tuft & Needle mattress has a rating of 6-7. This means that mattress has above-medium firmness. Still, it is quite comfortable and supportive.

The mattress conforms sleeper’s body well and does not sink in too much. Both layers of the mattress help relieve pains in back, hips, and shoulders by keeping the body properly aligned.

The mattress is supportive enough that you won’t feel any pressure points regardless of how heavy you may be.

On the firmness scale of 1-10, Signature Sleep mattress has a rating of 6. So it is a medium-firm mattress.

The mattress can conform to the sleeper’s body; however, its contouring properties are not as good as some other memory foam mattresses available on the market. As far as the comfort is concerned, the mattress doesn’t exhibit too much sinking when you sleep on it.

These properties make Signature Sleep mattresses an ideal choice for individuals who have lower back problems.

Zinus vs Tuft and Needle vs Signature Sleep - firmness


ZinusTuft and NeedleSignature Sleep
Zinus mattresses generally have very good cooling properties.

The bottom two layers of these mattresses keep them comfortable and cool, even in the summers.

Furthermore, the cover of Zinus mattresses also contributes to the overall cooling and heat retention as it contains tiny holes, allowing for good airflow.

The simple design of the Tuft & Needle mattress allows it to deliver enhanced breathability for a comfortable and cool sleep.

Both layers of the mattress have high density, which allows for good breathability without compromising support and firmness.

Furthermore, the adaptive foam used in the top layer is made with cooling gel and graphite which help with heat retention and keep you cool throughout the night.

When it comes to cooling, Signature Sleep mattresses dissipate heat well so you can expect no excessive heat build-up during your sleep.

Thanks to their breathable and limited body-contouring cover, Signature Sleep mattresses are very efficient at channeling the heat away.


ZinusTuft and NeedleSignature Sleep
Zinus mattresses are CertiPUR-US certified and their construction involves the usage of Castor Natural Seed Oil and Green Tea extract to get rid of bacteria and smells. Despite all of this, you can still expect a slight off-gassing or smell from these mattresses. But the smell is significantly less irritating than some other mattresses available on the market. You can expect the smell to disperse within a few days after unpacking the mattress.

As far as the environmental factor is concerned, Zinus’ hybrid and spring mattresses are very eco-friendly and don’t emit a lot of volatile organic compounds as most other mattresses do.

Tuft & Needle outperforms many other mattress brands when it comes to smell or off-gassing. There isn’t much ‘new mattress’ smell. And the smell disperses away in a matter of days after unpacking.

As far as the eco-friendliness is concerned, Tuft & Needle mattress has a CertiPUR-US certification. So you can rest easy knowing that the mattress is safe for you and the environment.

Unlike many other memory foam mattresses available on the market, Signature Sleep mattresses don’t have a ‘new mattress’ smell that lingers for months. There is a slight smell when you open the package for the first time, however, it goes away in a couple of days.

All Signature Sleep mattresses are CertiPUR-US certified, which means that they are eco-friendly and have no issues when it comes to health considerations. Their mattresses do not contain PBDE flame retardants, lead, mercury, heavy metals, as well as forbidden phthalates and formaldehyde.

Value for Money

ZinusTuft and NeedleSignature Sleep
Zinus combines unique design concepts with affordable prices and the end result is superb.

Not only are their mattresses the best in the entry-level mattress market, their prices are also highly competitive. Not to mention that these mattresses are very durable too.

So when you consider all these factors, you can easily conclude that Zinus mattresses offer excellent value for money.

Tuft & Needle mattress is very well priced.

It is manufactured using high-density foam which is very durable and gives the mattress a longer lifespan. Furthermore, the brand is well known when it comes to providing a great user experience and comfortable sleep.

All things considered, Tuft & Needle mattress offers good value for money.

Signature Sleep mattresses combine both comfort and quality at a great price, making them a great choice as compared to many other brands in the market.

Furthermore, these mattresses are very good when it comes to reducing motion transfer and isolating movements. They are also quite durable. These high-quality features and reasonable pricing makes Signature Sleep mattresses good value for money.

Comparing Brand and Design Idea

Following are some important aspects compared to these brands:

Zinus Brand

Zinus is a well-known mattress brand that offers quality mattresses at affordable prices.

Not only are their mattresses priced lower than most other brands, but they also have some innovative features such as the use of natural green tea extract for freshness, enhanced product safety, and reduced odor thanks to ActivCharcoal.

Furthermore, Zinus mattresses are also CertiPUR-US certified so they are eco-friendly.

There are three main types of Zinus mattresses: spring, memory foam, and hybrid.

Tuft & Needle Brand

Tuft & Needle is another mattress brand that offers some of the cheapest foam mattresses on the market, making them ideal for individuals who want to buy a quality product but have a limited budget.

Although the company is relatively new, its simple mattress design ideas (e.g. use of only two layers) and affordable prices attract a lot of customers. Their custom memory foam models are quite popular.

Signature Sleep Brand

Signature Sleep is a well-known and trusted mattress brand with a variety of models that have garnered the loyalty of many customers in a relatively short amount of time.

The company manufactures three types of mattresses: innerspring, memory foam, and hybrid.

Signature Sleep has gained popularity in the bed-making industry due to their quality products and affordable pricing.

You may also interestedOur Leesa vs. Simba Mattress Comparison

Zinus vs. Tuft and Needle vs. Signature Sleep (Pros and Cons)

ZinusTuft & NeedleSignature Sleep
  • Good motion isolation
  • Easy to maintain
  • Great cooling properties
  • Great value for money
  • The good conforming ability that leads to an increased level of comfort
  • Easier to move as compared to other mattresses
  • Good firmness and support, making them ideal for back sleepers
  • Ideal for couples and larger people
  • Great value for money
  • Signature Sleep offers the most affordable mattresses on the market.
  • Great for stomach sleepers and back sleepers
  • Great value for money if you use their mattress for short term
  • Firmness options are limited. Not recommended for side sleepers.
  • Not as durable as some other mattresses available on the market.
  • Poor edge support
  • The brand is not as well established as some others in the market.
  • Not recommended for side sleepers
  • Relatively shorter lifespan

Final Thoughts

You might like Zinus if

  • You want very little motion transfer and lower bounce.
  • You like medium level firmness for your mattress.
  • You aren’t a hot sleeper.
  • You are looking for a budget mattress.

You might like Tuft & Needle if

  • You want to buy a memory foam mattress but don’t like too much ‘sinking’.
  • You want a sleeping surface where you can adjust positions easily.
  • You don’t want frills.
  • You want the best mattress but have a limited budget.

You might like Signature Sleep if

  • Durability is not your primary concern.
  • You are a back or stomach sleeper.
  • You want good value for money.
  • You want to buy a quality mattress at a cheap price.